Shifts › Guides › W-2 vs 1099 for Per-Diem Nurses and Aides: What Each One Really Pays

W-2 vs 1099 for Per-Diem Nurses and Aides: What Each One Really Pays

Taxes, take-home pay, and protections compared, with real posted rates from live AllShifts markets.

Updated July 14, 2026 · live AllShifts shift data

The question behind the question

Per-diem platforms in nursing are split down the middle: some classify you as an employee (W-2), some as an independent contractor (1099), and a few let you choose. The hourly rate on the shift card does not tell you which deal you are getting, and the difference shows up months later, either as a smaller paycheck than you expected or as a tax bill you did not plan for. Here is what each status actually means, with the arithmetic done at real posted rates.

What W-2 means on a per-diem shift

• Taxes are withheld for you. Federal and state income tax plus your 7.65% share of Social Security and Medicare (FICA) come out of each check. No quarterly estimated payments, no April surprise.
• Your employer pays the other half of FICA. The matching 7.65% is paid on top of your rate, not out of it.
• You are covered. Workers' compensation if you are hurt on a shift, unemployment insurance credit, and the agency's liability coverage while you work.
• Overtime rules apply. Hours past 40 in a week are paid at time and a half under federal law.

What 1099 means on a per-diem shift

• Nothing is withheld. The full posted rate hits your account, but the taxes are still owed: you pay them yourself, usually quarterly.
• You owe both halves of FICA. Self-employment tax is 15.3% of your net earnings (both the employee and employer shares of Social Security and Medicare), on top of income tax.
• You can deduct work expenses. Mileage between facilities, uniforms, license and certification fees, and CEU costs can reduce your taxable income if you track them.
• No safety net. No workers' comp, no unemployment credit, no overtime premium, and you may need your own liability coverage.

The arithmetic at a real posted rate

Take a real market as the worked example: LPN shifts in Vineland, NJ are posted at $32.75-$37.18/hr right now. At the $37.18 median:

• As a W-2 employee, your FICA share is about $2.84 per hour, withheld automatically, and the agency pays the matching half.
• As a 1099 contractor, the self-employment tax you owe yourself is about $5.69 per hour before income tax. The check looks bigger; the after-tax difference is much smaller than it appears.

The rule of thumb that follows: a 1099 rate needs to be roughly 8% higher than a W-2 rate just to break even on the employer half of FICA, before you count workers' comp, unemployment, and overtime that W-2 includes. When you compare platforms, compare status-adjusted rates, not sticker rates.

What these rates look like right now

Every rate below is pulled from shifts posted in the AllShifts app today across 317 city markets in 34 states. Click any city for the live market page:

On AllShifts, you choose

AllShifts runs both models and lets you pick the one that fits your situation: W-2 if you want withholding, coverage, and simplicity; 1099 if you run your per-diem work like a business and want the deductions. Two things stay the same either way:

• The posted rate is visible before you book. Every shift card shows the hourly rate up front.
• Instant pay works on both. After your shift is verified, 100% of your net pay is sent by direct deposit or Zelle, 7 days a week, with no fees.

Common questions

Pay figures on this page come from shifts currently posted in the AllShifts app and change daily. AllShifts is an equal opportunity employer. All qualified applicants receive consideration without regard to race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, disability, or veteran status.